Two prevalent structures for overseas listings and their associated regulatory risks

1. Key Features of Red-Chip Structures

Red-chip structures typically involve setting up an offshore holding company that indirectly owns domestic assets. This model is widely adopted by Chinese enterprises seeking listings in Hong Kong or the U.S., given its relative stability and market acceptance.

• Offshore Holding: The offshore entity serves as the parent company, ensuring indirect control of domestic operations.
• Listing Efficiency: Well recognized by capital markets, especially for large-scale IPOs.
• Capital Flexibility: Facilitates equity incentive plans, cross-border financing, and international M&A.

2. Key Features of VIE Structures

• Contractual Control: Offshore entities control onshore operating companies in restricted sectors through contractual arrangements rather than equity ownership.
• Applicable Sectors: Common in industries with foreign investment restrictions, such as education, telecommunications, and internet services.
• Strengths and Risks: While VIE structures circumvent foreign ownership bans, their legal enforceability remains uncertain due to the lack of explicit statutory recognition.

‍

‍

‍

3. Comparison and Application Scenarios

• Legal Certainty: Red-chip structures are relatively stable due to equity ownership; VIE structures rely on contracts, exposing them to higher regulatory uncertainty.
• Industry Applicability: Red-chip structures suit most industries, whereas VIE structures are concentrated in sectors under foreign investment restrictions.
• Market Acceptance: Investors and exchanges are more comfortable with red-chip structures, while VIE arrangements often raise concerns about transparency and long-term stability.

Key Considerations

• Legal Risks: VIE contracts lack explicit statutory backing, while red-chip structures must navigate outbound investment and foreign exchange approvals.
• Regulatory Compliance: Both structures involve filings and approvals with the NDRC, MOFCOM, and SAFE, making transparency crucial.
• Taxation and Market Concerns: Cross-border share transfers may trigger double taxation, and capital markets often remain cautious toward VIE structures.

Conclusion

Red-chip and VIE structures remain important vehicles for Chinese enterprises to access overseas capital markets. However, neither is without risks. Companies must carefully evaluate industry characteristics, regulatory requirements, and long-term objectives before deciding which structure best aligns with sustainable growth.

‍